Drink Menu

We are proud to be the home of Whiskey Willy’s Bloody Mary Mix.

In 1985, Willy Grey was a bartender here at Cotton’s Restaurant.  While working here he perfected his own idea of how a good Bloody Mary should taste. After considerable experimentation he mastered his own special mix which he tried on the patrons who asked that he prepare it for “take out.”

Bottling and delivering the product involved long and tedious work; Willy filled each bottle by hand with a funnel and twisted the cap with a pair of pliers. It took 14 hours to make 14 cases and he did all this in Cotton’s kitchen.

It wasn’t long before grocery chains and restaurants across the nation were asking for his special blend. With limited space, Willy knew he would soon need a larger facility to keep pace with demand.  To finance this endeavor, he sold a treasured Babe Ruth uniform his grandfather had left him.  Finally, he was able to move production to a larger bottling plant and was supplying people across the United States with “Whiskey Willy’s” (almost world famous) Bloody Mary Mix. Willy’s only mission became simple – to provide people everywhere with a chance to experience the taste of a true Bloody Mary.

And, Willy says, there’s another perk, “It’s almost health food.”

He’s back!! Visit Whiskey Willy himself at the bar for the whole story and the perfect Bloody Mary.


Fully stocked assortment of domestic and imported beer.


Extensive wine list by the glass or bottle.


You can’t leave the island without first having the famous “Bushwacker.”  Cotton’s claims to have the first Bushwacker on the island.

We also have a wide selection of Exotic Frozen Tropical Drinks .

Prices subject to change without notice